RRSP Home Buyers’ Plan Repayment Rates…Dismal

RRSP Home Buyers Plan HBP

Drain your RRSP further to buy a new home. That’s what the government is encouraging with its newly increased RRSP Home Buyers’ Plan (HBP) limit, which just rose from $25,000 to $35,000.

You’ll probably draw your own conclusion as to whether that’s a good idea. We support it in limited cases, with caution. In fact, yours truly used it to buy his home.

But before anyone casts judgement, we’ve got some stats to drop on you.

The following numbers come from the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). It’s the most recently available HBP usage data. They’re for the 2017 tax year, which people would have filed in 2018.

Average annual users of the HBP: About 87,500 a year

Number of new HBP users in recent tax years: 

  • 83,230 in 2017
  • 88,280 in 2016
  • 91,000 in 2015
  • 88,680 in 2014
  • 86,570 in 2013

Number of people who made HBP repayments in 2017: 919,660

Does the HBP Make a Dent?

First time buyers tap RRSPs

The average first-time buyer this year will earn roughly $46,000 before tax if you extrapolate StatsCan data for 25- to 34-year-olds from 2017. After tax and withholdings, they put about $3000 a month in their jeans.

If that typical young buyer diligently saves 10% of her after-tax income and home prices don’t change, it would “only” take 6-7 years to save the minimum 5% ($23,418) down payment on today’s average $468,359 home. (Statistically, most first-time buyers purchase in the $300k range but our big cities are obviously much more expensive.)

So, if you’re lucky enough to have tens of thousands in your RRSP when you buy your first home, raiding your RRSP for the downpayment may seem appealing.

As we reported last week, however, only 20,250 people in 2017 used their full $25,000 HBP allowance, says CRA. So the new $35,000 limit won’t matter to three quarters of HBP participants.

HBP Risks

CRA Home Buyers PlanCRA wants you to pay back a minimum 1/15th of your HBP withdrawal each year for up to 15 years. Sure, you can skip these repayments. But if you do, you’ll pay income tax on the amount you didn’t repay.

For someone getting by with the average $3,000 a month take-home pay, HBP repayment is not trivial. We’re talking $1,667 per year if you borrow $25,000 and $2,333 if you borrow $35,000. That’s the equivalent of $139 and $194 each month, respectively.

It won’t surprise you then that hundreds of thousands of people miss their repayments each year.

Note that the repayment period starts in the second year after the year the individual withdraws funds from their RRSP. CRA says: “Of the 91,000 individuals who withdrew money from their RRSPs under the HBP in tax year 2015, 38,380 of them did not report any RRSP repayment (which is done on Line 246 of your tax return) for tax year 2017…”

That’s a whopping 42% of HBP users in that one year alone who failed to repay their RRSP!

Raising the limit to $35,000 will likely reduce total repayments even further.

But Wait, There’s More

The Home Buyers Plan effectively increases your debt ratiosMost lenders don’t even require HBP repayments to be included in their debt-ratio calculations. Those calculations are largely how they assess your ability to repay.

CMHC and Genworth Canada, the nation’s biggest default insurers, don’t require this either. A CMHC spokesperson explained, “A withdrawal of an RRSP under the HBP used as a down payment is not considered a debt obligation.”

“That being said, if an RRSP withdrawal has a related debt obligation outstanding (i.e., an RRSP loan that was used to fund the RRSP) CMHC would expect the related debt obligation to be included in the TDS Ratio calculation,” he said.

This means that someone could get approved for a mortgage and have obligations above and beyond what the lender is assuming. Mind you, some lenders do factor this in when adjudicating a mortgage application, but far from all.

In short, HBP repayments effectively lower debt serviceability for hundreds of thousands of first-time buyers. If incomes drop materially and/or debt levels keep climbing, that could somewhat reduce consumption and financial system stability. Some might argue that it’s also somewhat counterproductive to the government’s mission to deleverage Canadians.

The Next Wave of HBP Users

The Home Buyers Plan for DivorceesThere are roughly 300,000 first-time homebuyers in Canada each year, according to economist Will Dunning. His 2018 survey through Mortgage Professionals Canada suggested that 36% of recent homebuyers used RRSP HBP money to buy their home, but that accounted for just 10% of down payment funds.

Compare that to the roughly 100,000+ Canadians who get divorced each year, roughly three-quarters of which are homeowners already.

Starting in 2020, people who experience a “breakdown of a marriage or common-law partnership” will be able to tap their RRSPs to buy a new home, whether they’re first-time buyers or not. Those folks could eventually add tens of thousands of people to the HBP rolls each year.

These are people of all ages who have higher RRSP balances than a typical first-time buyer. That means the total down payment dollars coming from this cohort could eventually be sizeable.

By the way, the budget says this change is “proposed,” so it’s not technically guaranteed. We’ll see what happens post-election as prior proposed RRSP HBP changes have been shelved before.

In Sum

RRSP Home Buyers Plan pros and cons

We like the RRSP HBP for the right kind of borrower. That is, someone who’s a fit for homeownership, has no better source of down payment funds, and who knows how to make a budget and stick to it.

Among the other benefits, buying a home:

  • affords Canadians beneficial forced savings (that’s vital if families continue saving less and rely more on their home equity in retirement)
  • generally yields an inflation-beating long-term return, depending on where you’re buying
  • provides capital gains relief upon the sale of your principal residence.

The flexibility afforded by the HBP is positive if it helps you achieve such objectives.

But you’ve got to go in with realistic expectations of your ability to repay it. And, no financial decision would be intelligent without considering the trade-offs. For example:

  • How will blowing your RRSP on a home affect your overall liquidity, especially if your income drops for some reason?
  • Will HBP repayments cause you to take on more debt (to cover the repayment or the taxes if you don’t repay)
  • Will your after-tax real estate return exceed your RRSP return?
  • How diversified will your assets be after you buy a home?
  • How much would falling home prices impact your finances? (If you’re putting down only 5%, you could easily owe more on your mortgage than your home is worth.)
  • Could a housing correction restrict your ability to sell and move if you need to take a new job outside your city?

Long story short, the Home Buyers’ Plan (and home ownership in general) is not something to plunge right into.


For more info on HBP eligibility, see: RRSP Home Buyer’s Plan



8 Comments

  • GTA Homebuyer says:

    We used the HBP for our house and I must admit it was very difficult finding spare cash to make our payment on February 28. It definitely eats into the money you would have spent on other things.

  • Dll says:

    How about encouraging people to invest in our rrsp’s… then with the tax free savings method for a downpayment on a house …. More importantly also pay it back plus interest over the 15 years so don’t lose the resp investment…
    . but of course the banks and mortgage lenders wouldn’t like that because they would rather take your investment savings and then lend it back to youwith interest so it would not impact their profits …

  • Viv says:

    “they would rather take your investment savings and then lend it back to you with interest so it would not impact their profits”

    Sorry but how does that even make sense?

  • mapleman says:

    What happens if you invest in an RRSP and the market goes down or you pick bad investments? That could add years to your saving process.

  • Robkins says:

    We’ve been looking for a first-house for several years (longer than most, yes), and I’ve specifically put money in an RRSP for myself and a spousal RRSP for wife for the purposes of the HBP (eg that money was never earmarked for retirement).

    The RRSP investments were initially balanced mutual funds but are now cash/near-cash as we are hoping to finally pull the trigger soon and want to avoid downside risk in the market.

    This has allowed us to collect on meaningful tax refunds from the RRSP contributions that we’ve been able to plow right back into down payment savings. Those are refunds that we wouldn’t have otherwise been able to access if we kept the money in a TFSA or unregistered account. This is a financial highlight of a HBP strategy that is rarely talked about – and the 90-day attribution rule to pull money out of the RRSP is easy to comply with (as long as one is aware of it).

    It will be inconvenient to pay the HBP back (insofar as it would be nice to use the money for other things), but again this is a good semi-forced savings plan that will keep us contributing to our retirement fund.

  • The Spy says:

    Thanks Robkins. No doubt, the tax deferral is an HBP selling point.

  • Joe says:

    Wow I can’t believe how negative this article is regarding the HBP. It is probably the most under utilized tax tool for first time home buyers. The stats are dismal on the amount of people that use it and articles like this do no favours to increase the use of it.

    What that article fails to highlight is that fact that if you don’t pay back your portion owed to your RSP you ONLY HAVE TO PAY THE TAX ON THE AMOUNT OWED. On $35,000 ($2,333/year at 32% marginal tax rate is only $746.56/year in tax owed).

    Compare that value vs the strategy and it looks like this:

    $35,000 a person has sitting in their bank account waiting for their house purchase. It gets moved into the RRSP and assume an average tax rate of say 22%.

    That is an immediate guaranteed tax savings of $7700 (22% of $35k) as long as it stays in there for 91 days before they purchase the house.

    That is pretty well all the tax savings up front that can then be put back in to your RRSP, TFSA, or buy your furniture or do some renos, or knock down a car loan/credit card, or or or or or.

    All options so many people miss because they just save their money in a savings account until they buy. Or they’re tainted by articles like this with misinformation that skews the benefits of the plan.

    The reason most banks and advisors don’t advocate for the HBP is because there is zero incentive to have money come in and come out when you’re paid commission based on assets under management. God forbid there only be a benefit to the client. And a HUGE one at that!

    Every first time home buyer should explore the pros and cons of this plan for their particular situation. I would say in my career I rarely rarely see times that it doesn’t make complete sense.

    • The Spy says:

      Joe, Three points:

      1) Don’t confuse negativity with fact. As mentioned, we like the RRSP HBP for the right kind of borrower. But it’s irresponsible of any advisor to suggest this program makes “complete sense” for the overwhelming majority with no discussion of rate of return, repayment potential, debt serviceability, diversification, tax-sheltered investment growth, etc. For many, it’s simply not economically sound long-term, for the reasons stated.

      2) Regarding your statement: “What that article fails to highlight is that fact that if you don’t pay back your portion owed to your RSP you ONLY HAVE TO PAY THE TAX ON THE AMOUNT OWED.”
      Actually the article clearly states that. Re-read the sentence: “…you’ll pay income tax on the amount you didn’t repay.”

      3) Regarding your point about a “guaranteed tax savings of $7700,” that is mainly a tax deferral, not strictly savings. There’s a difference. The homeowner still pays tax when the money is withdrawn, albeit in the future and at a potentially different tax rate.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *